Immigration, the Rule of Law, and the American Dream: Dispelling the Myths and Upholding Our Values
- Ethan Justice
- 6 hours ago
- 3 min read
In today's political climate, immigration remains one of the most hotly debated issues in America. Unfortunately, much of the conversation is clouded by misinformation and emotional appeals that obscure the facts. One of the most widespread misconceptions is that crossing the border illegally is not a crime — merely a civil infraction. This claim is not only inaccurate but dangerous, as it undermines the rule of law, confuses the public, and disrespects those who follow the legal path to American citizenship.
The Law Is Clear: Illegal Entry Is a Crime
Let’s start with the legal reality. Under 8 U.S. Code § 1325, it is a federal misdemeanor to enter the United States illegally. A first-time offense can result in a fine and up to six months in prison. Repeated illegal entry is considered a felony under 8 U.S. Code § 1326, with more severe penalties. While some civil violations may occur during visa overstays or administrative errors, the act of crossing the border unlawfully is, by statute, a criminal offense.
The narrative that illegal entry is merely a civil offense is misleading and ignores established law. The distinction is crucial because it determines the legal process individuals go through and their potential penalties. When the law is broken, there are consequences — not because we are heartless, but because without consequences, law ceases to have meaning.
Separation of Families: Who Is Responsible?
Critics often cite family separation as proof of inhumane immigration policy. What they fail to mention is that when any American citizen is arrested for a crime — whether it's theft, drug possession, or assault — they are separated from their children. This is not an act of cruelty; it is a standard part of the criminal justice system, meant to ensure public safety and due process.
The same applies to illegal immigrants who knowingly break U.S. law. They are not being singled out. In fact, offering the option for parents to remain with their children in family detention centers — a policy often labeled as cruel — is a compassionate measure designed to preserve family unity within the bounds of the law. It is not ICE or Border Patrol agents who tear families apart; it is the parents choice to violate the law that puts children and families at risk.
Respecting the Law Is the First Step to the American Dream
America has always welcomed immigrants. Our nation was built by those who came seeking freedom and opportunity. But with opportunity comes responsibility. Respect for the law must be the first act of citizenship, not the last.
Illegal immigration undermines the very system that allows for legal immigration. It creates a black market for labor, drives down wages, and exploits vulnerable people who are often coerced into dangerous situations by human traffickers and cartels. Moreover, it sends a dangerous message: that the law is optional if your cause is emotionally compelling enough.
This not only erodes trust in government but also steals the opportunity from those who are trying to do things the right way — waiting in line, filing paperwork, learning the language, and abiding by our legal processes.
Employers Have a Role — and a Responsibility
The demand side of illegal immigration must also be addressed. Employers who hire illegal immigrants are violating federal law and enabling the problem. The process of verifying an employee’s legal status is straightforward. Tools like E-Verify, managed by the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), are free and easy to use. Employers who ignore this and knowingly hire undocumented workers are complicit and should be prosecuted. Turning a blind eye not only incentivizes illegal immigration but also undermines American workers and lawful immigrants.
Reforms Are Needed — But Until Then, We Must Uphold the Law
We can and should have a conversation about reforming our immigration system. We should have an orderly and fair system that expands legal pathways while securing our borders. But until reforms are passed by Congress and signed into law, we are bound by the existing laws — as is every immigrant seeking entry.
Supporting illegal immigration may feel compassionate in the moment, but in the long term, it corrupts the process, damages the rule of law, and delays the dream for those who respect our system.
If we want to preserve the American Dream — if we want it to mean something — we must insist that all who come here do so legally, with respect for our laws, our Constitution, and our values. Anything less is not compassion. It is chaos. Visit www.917society.org to learn more about our mission to promote Constitution Education.
Comments